vawa rfe processing time

See 8 CFR 214.14(c)(4). I assume that you already have a SSN right? [^ 40] For more information, see Chapter 4, Burden and Standards of Proof [1 USCIS-PM E.4]. The 2nd RFE came at the end of August 2022, where they wanted the updated medical exam etc..This entire process is lengthy & stressful. See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(2)(iii). Let me ask you, are you working w/an atty or doing everything on your own? I hope I hear back from them this week. [11], Primary Evidence that Does not Exist or Cannot be Obtained. Anyway, Ive done my part, gotten more documents & she has everything now. See Chapter 9, Rendering a Decision, Section B, Denials, Subsection 1, Denials Based on Lack of Legal Basis [1 USCIS-PM E.9(B)(1)]. The terms benefit request and immigration benefit request, as used in this Policy Manual part, include, but are not limited to, all requests funded by the Immigration Examinations Fee Account (IEFA). An unnecessary RFE or NOID can delay case completion and result in additional unnecessary costs to both the government and the benefit requestor. Ive spoken to her more than once about this, but she just does her own thing. My background is customer service & clerical, Im not a novice when it comes to paperwork or filing important documents. What is the difference between a direct and indirect victim? In addition, as of September 30, 2010, all birth certificates that were issued in Puerto Rico before July 1, 2010 are invalid. Therefore, the guidance in this table does not apply to these immigration benefits governed by different regulations. I filed for i-360 VAWA last year in July 2016. Who is eligible for VAWA cancellation of removal? And make sure after you got that everything Mitsubishi send it out because some of them will just throw your stuff by the side and continue what they are doing they are that mean! If the battered spouse or child waiver is approved, what will my immigration status be? For all VAWA applicants! What are the obstacles? [^ 66] See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv). 3 15. Last year I kept reaching out to her to find out what was going on w/my case. See 8 CFR 204.309(c). Unless otherwise specified, officers should generally follow these principles in each case: If the officer determines that the benefit requestor is eligible for the benefit requested (all the essential elements have been satisfied by the applicable standard of proof, including but not limited to, when applicable, that a favorable exercise of discretion is warranted), the officer approves the benefit request without issuance of an RFE or NOID. If my U visa application gets approved, when can I get lawful permanent residence (a green card)? I understand your frustration. I have been in the US since Sept 2015. Who qualifies for asylum? Review all the evidence to determine if each of the essential elements has been satisfied by the applicable standard of proof. We were now in the later half of February. [^ 39] See the program-specific part of the Policy Manual for more information on eligibility requirements that apply to a particular benefit request. I even found her on FB & sent a msg there. Can I request asylum if I am already in removal proceedings? VAWA Based on a Violence Against Women Act self-petition Total Days: 1298 days Case 2019-02-04 2022-08-25 Naivalf . [^ 10] See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(2). I already submitted my police certicates after submitting my app and receiving the receipt notices. [68], Additional Mailing Time When Residing Outside the United States or When an International Field Office Issues NOIDs. As that process is ongoing, USCIS has moved any remaining AFM content to its corresponding USCIS Policy Manual Part, in PDF format, until relevant AFM content has been properly incorporated into the USCIS Policy Manual. Requirement 1: You are or have been the victim of a "severe form of trafficking". Its just my mother & I & she would be alone, so I opted to continue w/the Vawa, but now I see that things arent getting any better w/this atty, I just feel like betting everything on black & taking a gamble on my mothers petition for me. In cases where the secondary evidence is insufficient, or where interview criteria indicate, USCIS may refer the benefit requestor for an in-person interview. Each privilege differs slightly in how it applies, such as whose testimony may be barred and who may invoke the privilege. I did my background check yesterday for school. Discrepancies in statements do not necessarily discredit the witness. Will I get an interpreter if I dont speak English? Shes gone ghost again on me. [49] To ensure consistency, officers should follow standard timeframes but may reduce the response time on a case-by-case basis after obtaining supervisory concurrence. See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(15). [26] A truthful witness, in speaking of a past event, might not repeatedly reproduce the facts in their entirety without some change in detail. @The chosen One ~ Thats what I believe has happened. What does it mean to have good moral character? What does it mean to have continued presence? The scope of the material covered by the privilege also differs.[28]. Can I travel outside of the U.S. if my U visa application is approved? If my self-petition is approved, when can I apply for lawful permanent residence (green card)? Total I-485 Processing Time 1. What can I do if law enforcement refuses to sign the certification? [8] If the requestor cannot obtain such primary evidence, the requestor must demonstrate that the required primary evidence does not exist or cannot be obtained and provide secondary evidence. If DOS shows that a record is generally not reliable in a particular country, USCIS should request secondary evidence. However, as of May 2021, USCIS is processing VAWA self-petitions that were filed about two years ago. 20082021 is a project of the National Network to End Domestic Violence, Inc. All rights reserved. Witnesses who have signed statements might later indicate that they wish to retract the statement, or they might give contrary testimony when later called upon to testify. This technical update replaces all instances of the term alien with noncitizen or other appropriate terms throughout the Policy Manual where possible, as used to refer to a person who meets the definition provided in INA 101(a)(3) [any person not a citizen or national of the United States]. 1988). All stuff my atty could have included in my initial pkg if she would have listened to me, but she had to do things HER way, & she set me back BIG TIME! Im not sure what my lawyer sent , I send her statement form friends I thought she would send it. @The chosen One ~ Thats the thing, The ONLY reason I know about the RFE is because I heard about lawfully. For all USCIS local field offices --> The average family I-485 processing times (the new '80%) is between 16.5 months (based on current USCIS data); The 'low' (or 50%) is between 11.5 months (this is an Immigration Planner estimate based on past data); The 'high' (or 93%) is at least 26 months (this is an Immigration Planner estimate based on . Whether in response to an RFE or a NOID, benefit requestors must submit all requested materials together at one time, along with the original RFE or NOID. However, USCIS has the discretion to deny a benefit request without issuing an RFE or NOID. See Volume 12, Citizenship and Naturalization, Part B, Naturalization Examination, Chapter 4, Results of the Naturalization Examination, Section B, Continuation of Examination, Subsection 1, Continuation to Request Evidence [12 USCIS-PM B.4(B)(1)]. Examples of supporting documents that requestors must generally present in the original are: Unless otherwise required, the requestor may submit a legible photocopy of any other supporting document at the time of filing.[22]. respond | Lawfully All Case Processing K Ka m Nov 14, 2021 VAWA RFE. Knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education must qualify the expert. That's really long timeline. [61] A NOID provides a benefit requestor with adequate notice and sufficient opportunity to respond and the opportunity to review and rebut derogatory information not known to the benefit requestor. H1B RFE and L1 visa RFE are the most common but, can be made in any visa application type. Vawa RFE. Whether evidence establishes the eligibility requirements is evaluated by the totality and quality of the evidence presented. USCIS may not prevent such witnesses from retracting or changing prior statements. @The chosen One ~ Now the next thing that concerns me is, with her not taking my case seriously by not giving me documents or answering RFE in a timely manner, what if USCIS thinks were not taking the case seriously? Will I have to testify about the abuse or be interviewed by the government? I had no choice but to contact the bar on her. Do you know she had my Prima Facie & never said anything to me? The NOID must clearly include the required response date, which includes the extra days for mailed NOIDs, when applicable. See Part B, Submission of Benefit Requests, Chapter 6, Submitting Requests, Section B, Intake Processing [1 USCIS-PM B.6(B)]. [^ 28] Officers should not confuse privileged testimony with confidentiality provisions. @kacy w ~ If you dont have it already, send a request to your atty asking for everything that shes done on your file so far. vawa rfe processing time. An officer may also take a sworn statement. See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(2)(iii). I think I am eligible for a T visa. Such interviews must be conducted with sensitivity and may warrant special considerations, including determining whether a trusted adult may be present. As cycle times improve, processing times will follow . 583 0 obj <>stream I just want to have my file so I can salvage whatever is left of it so I can get my GC & get on with my life. [^ 54] Due to the streamlined nature of the provisional unlawful presence waiver process and to avoid long delays in immigrant visa processing, a response time of 30 days applies to RFEs for the Form I-601A. In general, USCIS is also required to issue a NOID when derogatory information is uncovered during the course of the adjudication that is not known to the benefit requestor and USCIS intends to deny the benefit request on the basis of that derogatory information. The maximum response time for an RFE is 12 weeks (84 days); regulations prohibit officers from granting additional time to respond to an RFE.[48]. They wanted a more detailed declaration of what life was like w/my ex, how many sessions of therapy I attended, more documentation that we lived together, more bills in both names. To the extent that a provision in the USCIS Policy Manual conflicts with remaining AFM content or Policy Memoranda, the updated information in the USCIS Policy Manual prevails. @S S do you think this helped? See 8 CFR 204.2(e)(2)(i). See Volume 3, Humanitarian Protection and Parole [3 USCIS-PM]. That force led him to write and champion the groundbreaking Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) as a U.S. In the beginning she told me to get the psychological exam done, I did it, After she put my Vawa pkg together I asked her if she included the exam also. 44 U.S.C. If the benefit requestor either has not submitted all of the required initial evidence[46] for the benefit request, or the evidence in the record does not establish eligibility for the benefit sought, the officer should issue an RFE or NOID requesting such evidence unless the officer determines that there is no legal basis for the benefit request and no possibility that additional information or explanation will establish a legal basis for approval.[47]. Lets stay positive & hope for the best. The time to respond is the 6th of July. Sept will make 2 yrs. I dont know what the Efe is all about. No response. If an officer takes a written statement in a foreign language and a translator translates it into English, it may be necessary to produce the translator at a subsequent interview or hearing. Strict rules of evidence used in judicial proceedings do not apply in administrative proceedings, including benefits requests before USCIS. See Chapter 9, Rendering a Decision, Section B, Denials, Subsection 1, Denials Based on Lack of Legal Basis [1 USCIS-PM E.9(B)(1)]. Officers should explore each relevant fact uncovered in astatement by further questioning to the extent necessary before changing topics. How important is it to have an attorney help me? What If the USCIS Processing Time Seems Ridiculously Long? VAWA (I-360) Approval : March - 01-2021. @The chose One ~ Same here. I would strongly suggest that you consult with an experienced immigration attorney or an organizations that helps with VAWA applications to ensure that you all the necessary documents for the RFE for your VAWA case. USCIS changed their processing times from 24-31 months to 25.5 months. [^ 48] See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv). vawa rfe processing time. Im watching to see just how long it takes to get the GC. Send all inquiries there. [^ 52] For example, USCIS generally provides an applicant for naturalization 30 days (33 if mailed) to respond to an RFE. She tells me no, shell send it later. Set aside some time for this task. This is our lively holds their messing around with. However, contradictory statements may adversely impact the credibility of the witness.[27]. Cases requiring RFE processing are tracked as expedites throughout the RFE process, and when a response is . How do I prove that I contacted law enforcement? is this just like a formality or did the previous one get missing? If my U.S. citizen child is a victim of a crime, can I (the undocumented parent) qualify for a U visa? [^ 49] See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8). She didnt even tell me that she had moved her practice! Then the Washing machine broke down, it was like we were jinxed, something was always in the way. 2 USCIS-PM O - Part O - Religious Workers (R), 7 USCIS-PM O.5 - Chapter 5 - Other Special Laws. Therefore, officers and other USCIS staff must retain and enter into the administrative record the following: Written and signed affidavits from statements, such as sworn statements; Recordings and transcripts of interviews; Original notes made during site visits and surveillance operations; and. Or reach out & say, hey, just checking on you to see that youre alive, NOTHING. The average processing time for a Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) application is approximately 26 months, with some cases taking over 2.5 years to approve. [^ 30] If an officer intends to issue an adverse decision based on derogatory information of which the benefit requestor is unaware, the officer must disclose the information and provide the benefit requestor the opportunity to rebut the information and present information in the requestors own behalf. How can I prove that I suffered battery or extreme cruelty? @The chose One Oh okay. [^ 23] See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(4)-(5). When a sworn statement is taken and the affiant signs it, the affiant (the person making the statement) or authorized representative may request a copy of the statement. No way to know what they need until you actually get the letter which will probably arrive until Monday, hopefully earlier. 68 of 2009. If the battered spouse or child waiver is approved, how soon can I apply for citizenship? This content has been superseded by the current version available in the Guidance tab. For additional information related to the legislation that amended Puerto Rico law with respect to the issuance and validity of birth certificates, see S.B. It is fast. The wait wouldn't be so bad if they would just send these EAD's & Prima Facie's a lot sooner. I have two questions about VAWA RFE. The officer must structure the statement in a manner that is logical, using a clearprogression of facts and questions. What about a work permit and lawful permanent residence? Although the burden of proof to establish eligibility for an immigration benefit is on the benefit requestor,[43] an officer may assess, before issuing an RFE or a NOID, whether the information or evidence needed is available in USCIS records or systems. These goals are internal metrics that guide the backlog reduction efforts of the USCIS workforce and affect how long it takes the agency to process cases. How long will it take for my VAWA self-petition to be decided? How do I show that I am a victim of a crime? For additional information relating to electronic filings, see Part B, Submission of Benefit Requests, Chapter 6, Submitting Requests [1 USCIS-PM B.6]. Is it the same as having T visa status? [^ 70] See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(6). At first she said my mother could charge it on a card. USCIS typically announces such flexibilities on the USCIS website. We had a zoom meeting the following week. Officers frequently take testimony to determine eligibility for immigration benefits. Receipt of Application Approximately 2 to 4 Weeks After Filing If you properly file Form I-485, Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status, USCIS will initially respond by mailing you a receipt notice that confirms receipt of your application. If the evidence the requestor provides meets their burden of proof to establish eligibility,[4] USCIS approves the benefit request. When and how can I become a lawful permanent resident if I have asylum status? What does "persecution" mean? Requirement 4: You would suffer "extreme hardship involving unusual and severe harm" if removed or forced to leave. Identify the eligibility requirement(s) that has not been established and why the evidence submitted is insufficient; Identify any missing evidence specifically required by the applicable statute, regulation, or form instructions; Identify examples of other evidence that may be submitted to establish eligibility; and. What state are you in? [^ 55] Certain immigration benefits, such as refugee and asylum applications, are governed by different regulations and procedures regarding RFEs, NOIDs, denials, and failures to appear. The sworn statement becomes part of the permanent, official record and may be used in a subsequent proceeding or prosecution. @Pinky Lisa ~ I got a RFE last month. If so, did you include it in your pkg to USCIS? If DOS shows that a record is generally not available in a particular country, USCIS may accept secondary evidence without requiring the written statement from the issuing authority. For more information on confidentiality, see Part A, Public Services, Chapter 7, Privacy and Confidentiality. I cant believe this is happening! [^ 20] Secondary evidence may include optional submission of DNA results. Processing time after responding to medical RFE Hi, I applied for i485 in march 2020. [^ 43] See INA 291. How can they affect me? Where would I apply? She never once reached out to me to say, hey, just so you know, just bcoz you dont hear from me, doesnt mean Im not checking on your case. How long does my T visa status last and what happens when it expires? However, an officer should not issue an RFE or NOID if the officer determines the evidence already submitted establishes eligibility or ineligibility for the request. After I apply for a T-visa, what are the first documents that I will receive? See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(2)(ii). 1653, Law No. See Matter of Arthur (PDF), 16 I&N Dec. 558 (BIA 1978). VAWA self-petitioners may not be required to demonstrate that preferred primary or secondary evidence is unavailable. In certain circumstances, USCIS may consider responses to NOIDs submitted after the due date for response. @KP almost two years since I filed for VAWA and I havent received any RFE or whatever paperwork from USCIS. And then another 1-2 years for I-485 approval. [59], Derogatory Information Unknown to the Benefit Requestor. 1. If the VAWA cancellation of removal is approved, what can I get? Private documents include all documents other than the official records of legislative, judicial, or administrative bodies of government. Hi, my marriage based I-485 turned VAWA in 2018, VAWA Approved in 2020. received 5 EAD cards to date, no RFE requested. What about my family? See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(2)(iii). [25] An officer should only take testimony from a person who is mentally competent at the time set to testify. It was dated Oct 2020, but she was telling me she had gotten it just a few wks February? Yeah right! Upon request, USCIS provides a copy of the signed sworn statement to an affiant, without fee, at the conclusion of the interview where the statement was taken.[29]. Can they get T-visa status along with mine? However, certain immigration benefits, such as refugee and asylum applications, are governed by different regulations and procedures regarding RFEs, NOIDs, denials, and failures to appear; therefore, the guidance in this chapter does not apply to these immigration benefits governed by different regulations. I live in NY. 1 USCIS-PM E.1 - Chapter 1 - Purpose and Background, 1 USCIS-PM E.9 - Chapter 9 - Rendering a Decision, 1 USCIS-PM E.10 - Chapter 10 - Post-Decision Actions. A new proceeding will not be affected by the withdrawal or denial due to abandonment, but the facts and circumstances surrounding the priorbenefit requestwill otherwise be material to the newbenefit request. Therefore, the guidance in this section does not apply to these immigration benefits governed by different regulations. When I saw that a RFE had been sent on Apr 22 2021 & its now June, this is the nonsense Im talking about. After they received the RFE in Sept of last yr, THATS when I got my EAD. $47 for a drivers license for less than a month. Getting lawful permanent residence through a VAWA self-petition. Instead, the officers decision should give the specific reason(s) for the conclusion and refer to evidence in the record that supports the conclusion. I received a RFE for good moral conduct. That thing cost $500 & to not send it to USCIS is a waste of my money (mothers money actually) & she just re-traumatized me all over again. Likewise, a government-issued birth certificate is an example of primary evidence of the birth of a child, whereas a baptismal certificate is an example of secondary evidence of the birth of a child. USCIS has also developed internal goals for most types of petitions and applications. Step 1: You must have one of the "qualifying relationships" to the person abusing you. Records maintained by religious or faith-based organizations showing that a person was divorced at a certain time are an example of secondary evidence of the divorce. DOSs U.S. Visa: Reciprocity and Civil Documents by Country webpage provides country-specific information on the availability and reliability of various foreign documents. It got extended for 1 more year to respond. See 8 CFR 103.2(a)(7)(ii). Hard to tell, as my atty kept giving them to me when they were about to expire or had already expired! [51] These standard timeframes do not apply to circumstances in which a fixed maximum response time is specified by regulation. However, USCIS has determined as a matter of policy that additional mailing time (14 days) should be given to benefit requestors residing outside the United States or when USCIS mails an RFE from an international USCIS field office. In certain instances, the evidence provided in response to an RFE may raise eligibility questions that the officer did not identify during initial case review or open new lines of inquiry. If the officer determines a benefit request does not have any legal basis for approval, the officer should issue a denial without prior issuance of an RFE or a NOID.[38]. processing").2 To qualify as a VAWA self-petitioner for step one, the individual must be the abused spouse or child of a U.S. citizen or permanent resident, or the abused parent of a U.S. . It is also appropriate for officers to issue NOIDs in the following circumstances: The benefit requestor submitted little or no evidence;[63] or, The benefit requestor has met the eligibility requirements for the requested benefit or action but has not established that he or she warrants a favorable exercise of discretion (where there is also a discretionary component to the adjudication).[64]. Each time, he . Failure to submit requested evidence that is relevant to the adjudication is grounds for denying the request. If the case requires an RFE, the applicant has up to 87 days to respond to the RFE. 4 Sydney_5394 1 yr. ago Review our. On occasion, officers may require evidence from an expert to assist in completing an adjudication. What are the grounds of inadmissibility? When do I apply for a battered spouse or child waiver? I honestly hate thinking about my case as it just upsets me even more. In compliance with the regulations, the guidelines in the table below provide standard timeframes for benefit requestors to respond to RFEs. Documentary evidence may be divided into two categories: public documents and private documents. [^ 44] However, under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(17), officers must verify the status of an applicant or petitioner who claims that he or she is a lawful permanent resident by reviewing USCIS records. [^ 37] See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1). [^ 5] See Chapter 8, Discretionary Analysis [1-USCIS PM E.8]. Also, did you complete a psychological exam? [^ 42] See Chapter 9, Rendering a Decision, Section B, Denials, Subsection 1, Denials Based on Lack of Legal Basis [1 USCIS-PM E.9(B)(1)]. Youre holding up my case by replying so slowly. Each benefit request has specific eligibility requirements that a requestor must meet, which must be demonstrated by evidence. The determination of what evidence is credible and the weight to be given that evidence is within the sole discretion of USCISand determined on a case-by-case basis. [9] Any secondary evidence submitted must overcome the unavailability of primary evidence. How much does it cost to apply for a U visa? This website is funded in part through a grant from the Office for Victims of Crime, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice. See 8 CFR 103.2(b)(13). It's important to note that a green card application filed concurrently with a VAWA petition takes approximately one year longer than the VAWA case itself. I received a RFE for good moral conduct. I spoke to her on the 10th of August & she said she would send my pkg out ASAP. Step 2: You must prove that you were abused. [^ 27] Retraction of prior statements made under oath may, under certain conditions, render the witnesses liable for perjury. For example, in cases involving handwritten, counterfeit, or altered documents, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)s Homeland Security Investigations Forensic Laboratory may serve as experts. See 8 CFR 204.1(f)(1). See 8 CFR 208.14(d). Will I be deported if my T visa application is denied? This page was not helpful because the content: Part C - Biometrics Collection and Security Checks, Chapter 4 - Burden and Standards of Proof, Chapter 5 - Verification of Identifying Information, U.S. Visa: Reciprocity and Civil Documents by Country, Homeland Security Investigations Forensic Laboratory, Pub. USCISs processing times have changed over the years, and it is difficult to predict how long a self-petition that is filed now will take. If my self-petition is approved, what do I get? Do I need a lawyer to apply for a T visa or can I find the forms online? I believe my case is still with NBC. [18], Primary Evidence that is Generally Available but is Unreliable. If you don't receive a response or update within 94 days since USCIS originally sent you the RFE, it's a good idea to reach out to the USCIS Contact Center at 1-800-375-5283. Get processing time This discretion should only be used when warranted by circumstances as determined by the officer and the supervisor. Can men qualify for VAWA self-petitioning? Thats why I emailed her a reques for a zoom meeting bcoz I NEED a to know EXACTLY what shes done from what she hasnt done. In the meantime, our air conditioning broke down, we had to do with out for a month or so. If my spouse was already married to someone else when we got married, can I still qualify for a battered spouse waiver? In the absence of primary evidence as required by regulation,[14] the requestor must: Demonstrate that the required document does not exist or cannot be obtained by providing a written statement from the appropriate issuing authority attesting to the fact that no primary record exists and the reason the record does not exist;[15] and. Understand the specific elements required to demonstrate eligibility for the benefit request. Will being a victim of domestic or sexual violence qualify me? In any situation where the witness competency is in doubt, officers should supplement the record with the testimony of another witness, with other evidence relating to the same matter or reschedule the interview, per local procedures. Volume 1 - General Policies and Procedures, Volume 9 - Waivers and Other Forms of Relief, Volume 11 - Travel and Identity Documents, Volume 12 - Citizenship and Naturalization, Volume 3 - Humanitarian Protection and Parole. Im working with an attorney no I didnt do a psychology exam. U.S. [^ 69] Certain immigration benefits, such as refugee and asylum applications, are governed by different regulations and procedures regarding RFEs, NOIDs, denials, and failures to appear. Requirement 3: You are in the United States, a U.S. territory, American Samoa, or a port of entry of any of these because of human trafficking. Can I travel outside the U.S. after my T visa status is approved? The RFE should ask for all the evidence the officer anticipates needing to determine eligibility and should clearly state the deadline for response. [^ 63] USCIS generally issues RFEs when some required evidence is missing but may issue a NOID if all or most of the required evidence is missing. Any document containing a foreign language submitted in support of a benefit request must be accompanied by a full English language translation. Dec 2019. I think that was it. See 8 CFR 214.11(d)(2) and 8 CFR 214.11(d)(5). This technical update is part of an initiative to move existing policy guidance from the Adjudicators Field Manual (AFM) into the Policy Manual. 525 0 obj <> endobj What documents will I need in order to apply for a battered spouse or child waiver? omaha zoo board of directors, telemundo houston noticias de hoy, matte pink starbucks cup 2022,

Illinois Appellate Court, Allegheny County Section 8 Housing List, Greta Van Fleet Zodiac Signs, Columbia Southern University Lawsuit, Articles V